Tuesday, March 15, 2011

I never EVER want a feed.

Feed. is. weird. I have so many questioning thoughts about this novel! First of all, the lesions that all the characters have are DISGUSTING! They almost serve as a symbol of trends in modern-day societies: no matter how ugly or awful something is, if peers have one or are participating, we just jump on the badwagon! I wonder also if the lesions are a result of something harmful in the atmosphere. Maybe they are an exaggerated extension of the results of all the pollutants in our atmosphere today, since the novel is futuristic. Going back to the idea of the badwagon and lesions...this is a direct representation of how the characters cannot think for themselves because of the feed. In today's world, teens and young adults are already so easily influenced by friends and surroundings. Imagine if we had computers to think FOR us! This aspect of M.T. Anderson's book particularly scares me. It seems as though this is the direction in which our world is headed, the world where just a few generations below us could live. And the sad part is, they won't even realize how controlling and terrible technology is until it is ruling their lives. The characters in this book seem to think that the feed is the only way to think and communicate. They cannot fathom a time, nor want to, where people use their own thoughts and emotions to drive decisions and interactions. I do not want my children or my children's children to live in a world like this.

Feed does however have many positive aspects for our future students. The language personally drove me crazy as an English major, and was a challenge to get through at first. I was confused in certain parts of the novel where the characters would constantly switch back and forth between their own simple language and modern-day English. However I do think the language is very relatable to students, who spend their days using short responses in texts and on social networks. Another positive aspect of the novel for students is its text and length. Not only is the language itself quick and easy to read, but the format of the novel is not at all intimidating. The chapters are short, and the amount of text on each page is minimal. Finally, the themes presented in Anderson's story are fun and interesting to discuss with a class of high school students. Many extensions and activities could be used in a Feed unit in the classroom. We could have students communicate one class period only through texting or instant messaging, and ask them if the activity is similar or different to their real lives. Students could create a future world in a 3-D version (diorama) or a drawn version on poster board. To accompany this, they could submit a short paper listing both the positive and negative aspects of their created world.

I began Feed on the plane ride to my Spring break destination and quite honestly was like, "What the heck?!" at first. But once I read farther and got past the language a bit, I did enjoy it. :)

9 comments:

  1. I really like your idea of only being able to communicate through instant messaging as a class exercise. I think it would be fun and the students would really get into it. You always have awesome ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If we give this to our student three years down the road, they will easily be able to relate to the language in the book. I struggled with it a little bit because I think I've moved past that "lingo" stage. But I think it would be really interesting to gauge the students' reaction to the language in this book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "the lesions that all the characters have are DISGUSTING! They almost serve as a symbol of trends in modern-day societies: no matter how ugly or awful something is, if peers have one or are participating, we just jump on the badwagon!"

    The lesions were gross! I do agree that this is a symbol of today's society, though. My grandfather makes fun of me constantly for my "ripped and wholly" jeans because when he was a child they wore polos and slacks and always wanted to look nice. "Only the poor kids wore wholly jeans, you got your pants patched before you did this." So maybe this isn't bad as the lesions, but this is what they reminded me of when I read the novel.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with you -- I, too, found the language a little hard to get past, but once I did, I found the novel to be interesting and engaging. The thought of feeds being the future is a scary thought for me too. I know I depend heavily on social networking sites, especially twitter, but having a feed all the time seems like over-kill.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I personally dislike using online language (jk, lol,etc) so I also had a hard time reading this book too. However, I think that students today generally use a lot of online language. Not only would they enjoy reading this book but I think the general theme would strike a cord with them. I really like your activities for Feed because they are really interactive.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I also agree with the language. It took a little while to get used to and understand. Our students are going to be able to relate to this text quite more easily than we can. It may take some higher level thinking, but it will definitely be something than can make connections to. I also love the ideas you came up with to use with the text.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The language was awesome..so funny, (I feel kind of ashamed admitting this) but I've actually starting using the word "meg" and "ridic"....the words and phrases were pretty catchy overall, but some were just down right silly. I think it would be interesting to have students write their own short futuristic stories using futuristic slang and catch phrases. It would be a very interesting study on linguistics and language shifts.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I too had the what the heck attitude at the begining of the novel Feed. At first glance I was not sure if I was going to be able to get through it. THe language I found somewhat complex. Lets be honest it was out there. But I agree that this may have omething to offer our future student. I mean when we really think about it everyday life is a form of slang. Making this novel really relatable.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree that Feed was absolutely CRAZY, but at the same time such a scary shock of reality. The lesions were definitely disgusting, but at the same time it was funny they way EVERYONE wanted them because they were a fad. It reminds me of things we see on Europe's runways that are just ridiculous and ugly, but we all know that in five years sequin catsuits will be all the rage.

    ReplyDelete